You may have seen the negative news story a couple of weeks
ago about Feltham Young Offenders Institute after a report came out that said
it is an “unacceptably violent place”. The story was fresh in my mind as I
visited Feltham myself last week. It’s a couple of miles down the road from me,
and a good friend of mine volunteers there at the chaplaincy. For several years
they have been running a restorative justice course called “Sycamore Tree”,
which is based on the story of Zak and Jesus in the Bible (Luke 19). Some
inmates have the option of doing the course. Their families plus members of the
local community are invited to the last session, so I went along. Families and
the community are recognised as key to supporting young people who return to
their communities after ‘doing time’ in prison. The basic idea of the course is that justice
should not be only offender-focused, as our retributive system is, but also consider
the victim and the harm caused by the crime, and how to make amends. Among the issues discussed are taking
responsibility for wrong actions, restoration, and reconciliation.
Physically, Feltham is not a welcoming place. Why would it
be? But everyone we met gave us a warm welcome, from the staff at the various
checks to the young men taking the course. Warm was certainly the word as fifty
or so of us were ushered into the windowless prison chapel on one of the
hottest days of the year. What I wasn’t expecting was the warmth of enthusiasm
shown by the young men. And I wasn’t prepared for how moved I would be by their
stories.
Most of the course participants had written something
explaining what they had learnt from the course, which they read out to us. I
was impressed by their brutal honesty. It can’t be easy to talk about your
life, emotions, remorse and intentions for the future in front of thirty or so
strangers. But eleven out of thirteen of them chose to do so.
One boy from Essex explained how his life had taken a nose
dive when he was fourteen. He came home one day to find his brother dead. After
this it was an easy slide into gang culture and crime. But the course had
helped him to think about the direction of his life, about the hurt caused to
his victims, about taking responsibility for his actions. I spoke to him
afterwards, as we wolfed down my friend’s first class cake baked specially for
the occasion. He told me that his Mum had wanted to come for the presentation
but instead had gone to the funeral of a friend of his who had just been shot
dead. Under 21, he’s lost several other friends in the past, too. Sycamore Tree had made him think about his
life, and why he was still here. It was a wake up call for him.
Another young man had had the chance to meet his victims. He
explained that this was a decisive and liberating moment for him. They asked
him plenty of questions, but told him they forgave him and challenged him to
think carefully about consequences before jumping into a course of action.
A key element of the course is always the session when
someone who has been the victim of a crime comes in to describe his or her experience
and feelings. A few years ago I went in and described my experience of the
armed robbery my housemate and I had experienced in Nairobi. This time a father,
Dylan*, had shared with the participants how his son had been murdered, but he
had chosen to forgive the offenders almost immediately in order to break the cycle of violence and
revenge: if he hadn’t forgiven and urged his family to follow his example,
there would have been other killings in revenge. Listening to the course
participants relay back what Dylan had shared with them, it was obvious that
his example had had a profound effect on them. It had helped them understand
that the victim of a crime is a flesh and blood person with feelings, fears,
anger, grief, vulnerability, a life that can be blighted. But it had also shown
them that forgiveness is always possible and that it liberates people from a
cycle of destruction. It gave them hope that their victims might also forgive
them. And it challenged them about the possibility that they might need to
forgive others who had ohurt them. Several participants wrote letters of thanks
to Dylan for sharing his story with them. Their respect, admiration even, was
obvious. He was a role model seared in their memory, holding out hope.
The young men expressed their hope and determination to put
into practice what they’d learnt in their lives, both in prison and beyond
prison. There was honesty, of course, about how tough this would be. The
statistics are stark: two thirds of those who are in Feltham will end up
offending again within two years. More encouragingly, those who participate in
a restorative justice course are only half as likely to offend again. But out
of a prison population of 700, only thirteen had taken part this time. Finding
funding for the course is a challenge; this time it had come through donations
to the Prison Fellowship.
The encounter of Zak and Jesus is a powerful story of hope:
every moment is a chance for any one of us to make a fresh start, to take
responsibility for what we’ve done wrong, to be restored and reconciled, and
make amends. I went into Feltham with a negative news story reverberating in my
mind; I left with lots of food for thought and prayer, and a heartful of hope
for restoration.








